I took a few months off from dealing with my spam problems, choosing to stick my head in the sand. Probably not my wisest move…
In the interim, the opendmarc developers have been busy, releasing version 1.3.0, which also adds the nice feature of doing SPF checking internally. This lets me CLOSE WONTFIX the smf-spf and libspf2 packages from the Fedora review process and remove them from my system. “All code has bugs. Unmaintained code with bugs that you aren’t running can’t harm you.” New packages and the open Fedora review are available.
I’ve also had several complaints from friends, all @yahoo.com users, who have been sending mail to myself and family @domsch.com. In most cases, @domsch.com simply forwards the emails on to yet other mail provider – it’s providing a mail forwarding service for a vanity domain name. However, now that Yahoo and AOL are publishing DMARC p=reject rules, after smtp.domsch.com forwarded the mail on to its ultimate home, those downstream servers were rejecting the messages (presumably on SPF grounds – smtp.domsch.com isn’t a valid mail server for @yahoo.com).
My solution to this is a bit akward, but will work for a while. Instead of forwarding mail from domains with DMARC p=reject or p=quarantine, I now store them and serve them up via POP3/IMAP to their ultimate destination. I’m using procmail to do the forwarding:
SENDER=`formail -c -x Return-Path`
SENDMAILFLAGS="-oi -f $SENDER"
# forward all mail except dmarc policy reject|quarantine.
* ? formail -x'From:' | grep -o '[[:alnum:]+\.\_\-]*@[[:alnum:]+\.\_\-]*' | xargs opendmarc-check | egrep -s 'Domain policy: (reject|quarantine)'
This introduces quite a bit of latency (on the order of an hour) for mail delivery from my friends with @yahoo.com addresses, but it keeps them from getting rejected due to their email provider’s lousy choice of policy.
Tim Draegen, the guy behind the excellent dmarcian.com, is chairing a new IETF working group focusing on proper handling on “indirect email flows” such as mailing lists and vanity domain forwarding. I’m hoping to have time to get involved there. If you care, follow along on their mailing lists.
I’m choosing to ignore the fact that domsch.com is getting spoofed 800k times a week (as reported by 8 mail providers and visualized nicely on dmarcian.com), at least for now. I’m hoping the new working group can come up with a method to help solve this.
Do your friends use a mail service publishing DMARC p=reject? Has it caused problems for you? Let me know in the comments below.